Skip to content

Electoral reform and short-term problems in the U.S.

Party change or even just time is “solving” short-term problems that were targeted with electoral-system reform:

  1. Voting for third parties. Going back 25 years or so, many saw “first-past-the-post” as the main barrier to third-party voting. This belief drew from experiences with Green and Libertarian presidential runs in the 1990s. Now the Working Families Party is doing well in places with all sorts of rules: at-large elections with limited voting/nominations, nonpartisan elections, and of course fusion.
  2. U.S. House control. Gerrymandering and the removal of majority-minority districts were expected to entrench Republican control. They did not.
  3. U.S. Senate control. Staggered elections and the “deep redness” of some states were expected to entrench Republican control. They did not.

It will be interesting to see where things go. As some pointed out this weekend, the “blue wave” proceeded in a context without federal voting-rights protections (here is a story that stimulated such comments). Local-level adoptions of alternative electoral systems continued. There is pressure on state governments to reduce taxation, and housing/affordability remain salient. Buttigieg endorsed proportional representation on a podcast. Finally, many have noted that a sizable swing in the opposite direction of the wave is possible.


How to have two votes in DC’s at-large elections

There is controversy about the new electoral system in DC. Michael Brice-Saddler reports for the Washington Sun:

For decades, the at-large ballot carried simple instructions: vote for no more than two candidates. Under the new system, voters face a grid prompting them to rank candidates across columns from first to fifth choice. Yet because each ballot contains only one active vote at a time, a voter’s second choice may never be counted.

The new math has forced candidates to reshape their messaging in the home stretch, with contenders aggressively pleading for first-choice votes. The change has also bred friction among voters accustomed to casting two distinct picks, leaving even politically plugged-in residents puzzling over their ballots.

One way for voters to have two “active votes” — or potentially as many as they want — would be to use free-list PR (FLPR). Also known as PR with panachage, FLPR lets voters cast an arbitrarily large number of candidate votes. These then determine how many seats each party gets as well as which candidates get them.

Read more…